NSSN: bad sound, flat performances from Phoenix
by svashtar on 12/12/10HP Pavilion At San Jose - San JoseNot So Silent Night last night left a lot to be desired. I went because I really like My Chemical Romance and Broken Bells, and I'd always wanted to see Smashing Pumpkins live. The other bands in the line-up were Black Keys and Phoenix. I suppose part of the issue is the night before the event, I got an email from Live105 stating that everything had been moved down an hour so the show was going to start at 6, instead of 7. This wouldn't be a problem, except that this was on a Friday night in Downtown San Jose at the peak of rush hour, and we were coming from Fremont. Also, the one band I really wanted to see was first onstage. Because of the traffic on 680, we ended up missing Broken Bells. I managed to catch the final 10 seconds of their performance from the outside of the venue. Once inside, the view was pretty good; we were up in the tier closest to the stage. The Quick n' Dirty Reviews Black Keys While I'm not a huge fan of their music, it's reasonably well-done and bluesy. I have to give them props for being the only blues band on an alternative radio station. The trouble with this band and, indeed, all the other bands at the show, is the sound quality was terrible. Whoever ran the sound needs a serious flogging with Roman whips; the kind with the metal tips at the ends of the thongs. It was difficult to tell which song was which because the distortion was so rampant. I could kind of make out their one big hit on the radio, but most frustrating was I couldn't make out any words because the vocals were too low. Phoenix It's clear the teen-aged girls think the lead singer is cute, but I have to use the one word I don't want to use here. This band SUCKS. Again, the sound quality was atrocious, which wasn't the fault of the band, but the flat notes and the off-key singing was like having someone chew aluminum foil at you. I have to give these guys some credit for acting as if they were the headlining act. They did *try*. But. . .they sucked horribly. Their performance was bad enough to prompt me to send a text to the radio station to let them know Phoenix was making my ears bleed. My Chemical Romance They made the best of a bad situation better than any of the other bands. They overcame amazing handicaps to put on a good show. It was clear the lead singer was not happy, but he was enthusiastic until the very end. The songs did feel rushed, and because the sound was so muddy on the vocals it was hard to tell what he was singing. They powered through Na Na Na, which I'm sure was a contractual obligation for the show. The Black Parade was recognizable, and he put on a great performance in spite of the poor sound quality. Teenagers was a fun anthem, as well. Smashing Pumpkins I'm glad I put up with all of the frustrations of a poor sounding show, because the Pumpkins rocked the house. It was clear that Billy Corgan was not happy about something. My guess is the poor sound quality, coupled with the possibility that he was told what to play, and having to wait until 10:30 to start, that this just put him into a foul mood. The rest of the band seemed checked out in terms of their facial expression, but their body mechanics and their playing were fantastic. They were real pros making the best of a bad situation. I might be biased because I really do like this band, but I can't help thinking they were the highlight of the show. A day later, I felt disappointed. There were a lot of good songs and interesting melodies that I couldn't hear during the show. I don't think I'll take it for granted when I go to shows that are well produced and sound great. Recent examples include: Roger Waters: The Wall, The Cure, Silversun Pickups, Blondie, B-52's, and Muse. My lesson is learned. The next time I want to see a particular band, I will simply get tickets to see Just Them. I would not go to another Not So Silent Night.