Who planned this event?
by DavidM70 on 7/23/10The Chicago Theatre - ChicagoRating: 2 out of 5My love for Natalie Merchant goes all the way back to the beginning with 10,000 Maniacs. I've been on board for a LONG time, so when Ticketmaster sent me a pre-concert notice, I made sure I was in front of my computer the minute tickets went on sale.
After months of anticipation, I was even more thrilled when Natalie walked out on stage without a warm-up act. This was going to be awesome! Except, it wasn't. Natalie took us by the hand an awkwardly navigated us thru 15 songs from her new album, which was based on some very obscure children's poetry. Mind you, the songs were exquisite; complete with the vocals and instrumentations we've come to love. However, the ham-handed execution made these 90 minutes almost painful to endure. As she began the "final" song, she informed the audience this would be the "last song of the evening", and the band took bows and exited the stage. A reasonable number of fans exited the event, as well.
To nobody's surprise, Natalie came back out for an encore, which wasn't an encore at all. It was a "second set without an intermission". It was her "how do we please everyone" set. Even though we got many of Natalie's biggest hits, including a very pleasing version of one of my all-time favorites (Cowboy Romance), the overall execution was still awkward. On a number of occasions, Natalie made references to "pleasing" the audience; also asking "what more could you all want". It was almost like she felt she "had to" play a few of the songs the audience came to see. Go figure!?!?
Musically, this is the Natalie Merchant I wanted to see, make no mistake. But the set was so awkwardly executed, it made the music nearly impossible to enjoy. If Natalie would have opened with a few favorites to get everyone into the music, then followed by taking a minute to explain the basis of her new material (injecting those 15 songs into the 2 1/2 hour show), my opinion may have been very different. Instead, the long and meaningless biographies of some very obscure poets completely spoiled it for me. I just never connected with the artist, so by the time a few of the familiar pieces were being performed (especially since Natalie's attitude was that she needed to "please" the audience), I honestly shared Natalie's disdain for them.
By the time of the final song, 20 percent of the audience had gone home. I'm glad I stayed to hear Cowboy Romance, but even that piece, complete with an interruption by a very inconsiderate fan, was pretty hard to enjoy.