Doesn't live up to original
by ABNorm on 4/1/12Cobb Energy Performing Arts Centre - AtlantaI was fairly disappointed! Glad I went, but once will be enough. I've loved Young Frankenstein, the movie, since it came out in the 70's. Hearing every good line repeated may have been to be expected, but there was so much more that could have been done with the material to turn it into a memorable night at the theatre. I was expecting the musical to take it to a whole new level, but it fell flat. The gags were there, but the timing on them was awful. I was also expecting some of the classic moments of the movie to be written into song, but virtually all the musical numbers were basically just scene set-ups. How great would it have been to write the blind man scene into a song to go along with the soup, the wine, and the cigars? Instead, the song was just the blind hermit singing about being lonely before the monster showed up. And there were several other missed opportunities like Abby Normal, What Knockers and so on. Instead I was left with the impression that it was half-hearted attempt to cash in on the well received Producers conversion. Christopher Timson's Igor was played over-the-top and overtly gay, not at all in keeping with the dead-pan smart-aleck Igor that Marty Feldman created. Lexie Dorsetts' Elizabeth severely missed Madeline Kahn's brilliant touch on the wise-cracking and innuendo, but at least Ms. Dorsett brought a great voice to the part. Standouts were Rory Donovan as The Monster and Elizabeth Pawlowski as Inga. Other saving graces included a highly entertaining Puttin' on the Ritz number and plausible performances by A.J. Holmes as Frederick Frankenstein and Pat Sibley as Frau Blucher. All in all, I guess it was entertaining, but I still came away feeling my night may have been better spent watching the movie for the umpteenth time... hilarious script, spot-on timing and absolutely perfect cast... not an easy thing to replicate.