It's ALL about the voices.
by Leeeese on 8/4/10Potawatomi Casino/Northern Lights Theater - MilwaukeeRating: 4 out of 5OH, those voices. I was impressed by how strong, resonant, on-pitch and WONDERFUL Clay's and Ruben's voices were in person. I had only seen them on TV before last night, and they're even more impressive in person. The power behind those perfect voices is mind-boggling, and I found myself wanting to hear more, more, more.
The concert consisted of song montages, grouped by decade, with Clay and Ruben taking turns on lead. In between each decade, one or both of the guys would do a full solo or duet song. I far preferred the full songs. The montages, though sung perfectly, were bordering on cheesy variety show in feel. I do believe this was part of the intent, for them not to take themselves or the show too seriously, but it was almost a little bit too much.
Clay and Ruben did comedy bits, for lack of a better phrase, in between the songs. They were mildly funny, and quite endearing, honestly, for a fan like me. But they weren't very polished, and the material was not first-rate. I'm just being honest; I didn't mind any of it one bit, but I do think unless you're truly a Clay or Ruben fan, you might find it stale or slow. I kind of welcomed the break from the decibels.
Like I said, I think they made a purposeful effort to make the show approachable, not too high-brow, not take themselves too seriously, etc. They made a nod or two at Clay's homosexuality during the "comedy bit" portions of the show. I wasn't sure what the purpose was, and kept trying to figure out if they were trying to diffuse any discomfort there might be among his audience about it, or trying to frame it in a lighthearted "Yes, I'm gay, but I'm still the same Clay you always knew" kind of light. It seemed somehow off the mark, to me, though, but not a big deal.
I found the venue to be maybe a bit too small for their sound. It was LOUD. Ear-piercingly LOUD. And I was near the back of the balcony. I'm guessing those down front were in pain.
The band was EXCELLENT. I don't know who the band is, but they are top-notch, and I think the live band was essential for a show like this. If it had been just the two guys and piped-in music, it would've been a disappointment, even with those voices.
The backup singers had impressive voices and held their own with Clay and Ruben. They were truly VERY impressive, belting out songs by artists like Aretha Franklin and pulling them off beautifully. BUT, they could sure use a lesson in style or stage presence. For me, they were quite distracting, visually and detracted from the classiness of the performance.
If I had one negative thing to say about Clay and/or Ruben it would only be this little bit: Please wait until the audience stops laughing before continuing with the next line!! I missed a good bit of the comedy bits, just because they seemed rushed and didn't wait for the audience noise to die down before proceeding. Even when the audience was silent, they were sometimes speaking too quickly, or holding the mike too far from their mouths during the talking parts. This could easily be fixed to make the show far more enjoyable.
To recap: AMAZING, perfect, addictive voices. The talent in the room was beyond belief.
There is a lot more these two could do with that talent... and hopefully they will. :)
I overheard this from one young lady as we were filing out of the theater: "My face hurts from smiling too much!" That's definitely a sign of a good concert experience. :)