There were some cool things about the show - a lot of the silly lyrics and music motifs were changed for this revival, and I liked the new orchestrations as well. The lighting and sets were really cool and inventive, but like the rest of the show, it felt very overworked and heavy toward the end. I have never felt the ending of a show drag for so long!
The first half of the show was great with the exception of the "Take Me As I Am" scene between Emma and Jekyll, which I felt was much too treacly both in its delivery but also unfortunately the song itself. Constantine Maroulis was quite enjoyable though I personally had trouble adjusting to the endings he places on the ends of his sentences as a result of his accent; his sharp breathing between the teeth prior to singing a phrase was also distracting but I thankfully stopped noticing it throughout the show. His redemption is the fact that he can blow the roof off any end note. Teal Hicks's song delivery was also very distracting in that she does not enunciate when she is not belting and also decreases her vocal volume after singing each word such that if I had not already known this show beforehand, I would not have had any idea what she was singing! I was very impressed with Deborah Cox, but what disappointed me ultimately about her is that she seemed to have been completely out of her element while singing "Someone Like You" and "In His Eyes". It was as if Lucy had no idea who she was or how to sing a song when she wasn't Lucy the Dancer at Spider and had something to hold onto and dance on, and that was quite disappointing! Thankfully (again), I felt she really redeemed herself in "A New World" so I left happy about Deborah Cox.
Two final things: I understand why the Hyde portion of the "Confrontation" was video taped (I assume partly as a mechanism in which to save Maroulis's voice and not shred it each night), but to me, it came at a point when I was done seeing theatrics and just wanted to feel the internal struggle coming between these two personalities, and I thought it was way too over the top. The second and last thing is the pacing after "A New World" - as I mentioned, "Confrontation" came at a time when I was getting tired of the show, and at this point the pacing should get much faster. For some reason, I felt like I was being dragged by the show starting at the point when Hyde turns back into Jekyll, deals with the murdered Lucy, and then goes on and gets married, and then dies. This all happened so slowly! Jekyll died so slowly! In the current pacing, I was feeling "Ok, we get it, he's going to die, he's not going to make it as a living Jekyll", but if the death scene happened faster, I think I would have been in much more shock about the whole situation morally and left me a lot more emotionally attached to the ending.