I was impressed with a lot of things in this production, but ultimately, the story was poorly constructed.
First, I thought the cast was excellent. From better known stars to those lesser known supporting cast, the vocal quality was excellent. Big props to Billy Burke! Who knew he had such a deep, rich and controlled voice?
Second, I thought the music was also excellent. I could definitely hear John Mellencamp's influence throughout all the songs, (to the point of using Shazam on some, because I was convinced I had heard it before.) Love or hate his music, he is the sound of middle America, and it was a perfect fit for the subject matter.
Third, T Bone Burnett's arrangement was beautiful. The musicians were excellent, and the types of instruments used pulled that Americana feeling out of Mellencamp's music.
I also felt the staging was different and innovative. The characters sit in semi-circle and come forward to tell their stories, sing their songs, or move the play along. As they act center stage, all others listen quietly, strongly evoking the classic story circle of all our ghost story memories.
Unfortunately, the writing is where this play fell into the fire. Like many promising efforts I have witnessed, it starts strong, but finishes badly. Joe sits in a bar, contemplating his life and past mistakes. We come to realize that this is taking place in his mind. This allows us to suspend belief and accept the characters of the devil and the narrator, along with the ghosts, as members of the cast. I also found the parallels the story drew between Joe's feuding brothers and feuding sons as compelling and promising. Ultimately though, I felt Mr King could not come up with an ending that supported the beginning, and one that the beginning deserved. Mr King concludes the play in a maelstrom of violence and death that absolutely does not make sense! This was made even more awkward by the actions of characters that were, in essence, out of character, simply because the time wasn't taken to develop the characters. Also, I found the character of the ghost of the caretaker character extremely contrived. I have a feeling, when it was being written, someone said, "We need a character who can sing deep and soulful." Someone else responded, "Let's include an old black caretaker!"
Overall, I really enjoyed the music, acting and staging, but the story was weak and completely fell apart at the end.