For Rodgers and Hammerstein, part of the magic that makes the musicals work are the elaborate orchestrations and group dance numbers. Going in, I read that they found a way to stay true to the script, but with a different delivery. Oklahoma being a movie I grew up with thanks to my parents & grandma, I knew every line coming. It was disappointing how not even lines that could be said sarcastically or jokingly were just delivered so flattly. Aunt Eller & Laurie particularly. It kept feeling like they were just reciting words and I couldn't feel empathy or want to root for the characters...
I felt the dialogue was delivered like reading a monotone script at parts. The engaging moments like Ado Annies character being more promiscuous was great, but she outshined her coactors or Will & Ali. It felt unbalanced. I felt super disconnected and unsympathetic to the other characters. I expected chemestry between Laurie & Curly. And I didn't get that.
The dream sequence bothered me the most. At it's core, the dream sequence is supposed to make it clear for Laurie her decision. I'll caveat that I'm not well versed in appreciating all of interpretive modern dance, but it felt like a very talented modern dancer moving to the music, but nothing made sense in tying it back to the story of helping Laurie see Curly-Yes, Jud-No. Even tho I was disappointed that the iconic can-can dancers weren't there, I think I would've been ok with it had the dance scene actually moved the story.
What a disappointment...