Disappointing Performance
by Saenger on 3/4/10ST ANNE CHAPEL - MARYLHURST UNIVERSITY - MARYLHURSTRating: 2 out of 5What can one reasonably expect from a musical evening with 10-14 year olds? Answer: Not much great music but interesting. What should one reasonably expect from a musical evening with the Vienna Boys Choir? Answer: A lot of great music superbly performed. Sad to say, that wasn't this listener's experience. To put a fine point on it, in general, the group of 25 sounded tired and ragged, and annoyingly uneven in tone, ranging from the sweet and modulated to the harsh and brassy, especially in the form of one (too often featured) soloist in the soprano section; this is a choir, not a talent show. In that regard, the disparity of vocal talent among the choir's members in a group touted to be "One of the world's oldest and most famous," was especially disappointing. As for the music, on paper the program looked promising in its diversity, but only a few of the classical and Austrian folksongs delivered the anticipated cultural connections which this listener entered the hall expecting to hear in abundance. The director of this group of admittedly talented kids needs to listen a lot more to how his boys are delivering on their 500 years of history, and get someone else to perform the accompaniment. On a (more) positive note, it was reassuring to know that a significant portion of the high-ticket price was going to support some important international humanitarian efforts.