Not what I expected
by Greenville Psul on 3/11/25Atlanta Symphony Hall - AtlantaRating: 3 out of 5We had never heard the Atlanta Symphony, and thought it would be an interesting experience. It certainly was interesting, although not always in a good way.
The concert consisted of two Beethoven symphonies. The orchestra played with zest and engagement, but intonation problems and sloppy entrances were too common. I’ve heard many small regional orchestras play more accurately.
The overall interpretation was fine, but the underlying problem is that they have a very large sound system “enhancing” the Orchestra. Microphones are placed everywhere overhead, and whoever was at the mixing panel was really amping up the bass instruments and French horns to the point where they dominated the entire ensemble. In some sections, the horns sounded distorted and blasting; not quite sure if that was the way they were playing or the artificial effects of the sound system.
Pianissimo sections came across as forte, and forte sections came across as 90 decibel thunder. The auditorium is acoustically very “live”, but when the sound reinforcement is added, it becomes overwhelming. Far more suited for a pops concert, or backing up for a mainstream singer than for a Symphony performance. I’ve been to hundreds of Beethoven concerts, but never heard a live one at that volume level. The performance eventually lost any sense of intimacy and nuance, and it was really hard to tell if the instrumental sections was well balanced, or if they were relying on the sound system to compensate for any sectional weaknesses. Toward the end of the 7th, it became a thundering muddle.
The audience seemed to love it, so perhaps they’re used to sound-system-enhanced “pop concert” symphonies in Atlanta. I can honestly say that I enjoyed portions of the performance, but other parts came across as overwhelmingly loud, blasting and exaggerated, so we probably won’t be back.
Four stars for enthusiasm, good tempos, and energy. Three stars for somewhat sloppy ensemble playing, and one star for the “ rock concert“ environment.