I've been a fan of Madeleine Peyroux for almost 20 years so I was excited for this concert. Sony Hall has significant disadvantages as a venue, though. Many reminders told us that our general admission tickets would be first come, first served for seating. Fine. We got there early to get a good seat but were herded into the hall among the first to arrive and were taken to our seats by an usher who was trained to show us to specific seats, hence no choice at all, really. The tables for us, as well as for the VIP ticket holders, were long and assembled in rows that allowed for impossibly tight seating. We aren't even overweight but for those who are, this would be impossible. The chairs themselves were completely absurd...rickety and massively uncomfortable. I don't have a bad back but I did have a horrible backache after the concert. Our waiter was good, friendly, competent, so no problem there. The prices were high but not surprising.
As for the concert itself, it started 30 minutes late, especially annoying given the ridiculous chairs we were sitting on. The woman sitting next to me is a performing musician, too, and she remarked on how male musicians never seem to think of dressing for a performance while women are expected to. Madeleine Peyroux wore an attractive outfit that complimented her heavier body shape and it was easy for her to attach her various instruments to a strap around her neck, all very effective. The keyboard player looked like he was wearing a shirt he had slept in and he was prominently featured in the front. He was very good, but that aspect was wanting. Her repertoire was fine for me with many familiar favorites along with newer songs. Her voice was superb and I enjoyed her commentary between songs. I did not enjoy how many times she featured the back-up musicians though. We appreciated them with applause too often. It was MP we were there to see and hear, not them. They were very good, no doubt about it, but they didn't merit that much attention. The end of the concert was a bit bizarre. MP seemed uncertain about doing an encore, then returned to do one, and it was somehow ineffective as a song choice, again focusing too much attention on her backup. A bit disappointing as a concert conclusion.