My review has two parts. For SHINee themselves, they did an amazing job! The emcee explained how they had come from Seoul to Toronto to Los Angeles and now Chicago: all in only three days, and so they must have been exhausted, but you certainly couldn't tell. They gave the songs, dances, Q & A, and games all their energy and personality and talent. They sang Hello, Replay, View, Lucifer, and Sherlock, and were fantastic. The audience couldn't stop screaming with excitement. So for the SHINee members, I give them an A+.
The second part of my review is for the organization of the event itself. It was very disorganized. There were at least four different lines to get in to the venue and it was a big mess inside, as well. Plus the emcee was terrible. He didn't have an appealing personality, didn't seem enthusiastic, kept interrupting the guys when they were talking (Dude! We didn't come here to hear YOU talk!), and people in the audience who spoke Korean said that he only got the interpretations correct about 75% of the time, so it left me wondering what we missed! I wish they had gotten a better emcee, and that they had been more organized during the process of letting everyone in, handing out the merchandise, and getting everyone seated. It was pretty chaotic. Also - this made me so mad: There were 20 people picked to go on stage to play charades with SHINee, and the way the production company picked the people was just choosing people that were waiting there at noon (seven hours before the show). That was totally unfair. A lot of people couldn't be waiting there that early. They should have chosen people randomly so that everyone had a chance to be on stage.
Anyway, I would definitely recommend another SHINee fanmeet or concert, but I hope they hire a different company to run the event.