I've been a huge fan of Mae since the Everglow. I've been to nearly every show that's been in Virginia of theirs since then. They have historically put on a great, well-balanced show that shows a great deal of professionalism mixed with joy and self-expression.
This was not the Mae I once knew.
I didn't catch the names of their opening bands, but the first one was fantastic. Fun, upbeat, and knew how to get the crowd going. The second... sounded like a broken record after a few tunes. Everyone around me was feeling the same way - not a bad band, but... needed a tremendous amount of diversity in their playing.
But what caught me really off-guard was that there were openers at all. No one actually knew that anyone was opening for Mae.
Then Mae came on for their hour-long set. Starting off with a song from Singularity (uhm... why?), and queueing up the "welcome to the everglow" backing track 3 songs in was a little off, but I stuck with it. The mix in the room was mediocre, at best. The guitars were too shrill, yet, somehow, muddy. Heavier parts to the songs were weak and non-moving. The background vocals were way too loud and dry, and Rob's keys were almost invisible.
All night, Jacob, Mark, and Rob (what I could hear of him at least) nailed it. Their playing was solid as ever, and they were enjoying themselves.
However, the biggest problems came from the interplay between Zach and Dave. Dave was horribly off-key all night. Not enough that my wife with no musical background noticed, but enough that my ear couldn't help but hear note after wretched note being sung flat. Some of my favorite songs sounded simply butchered.
And Zach... it's apparent he's been messing with his sound. As a musician myself, I can't fault him - I do the same thing quite often. But his new tone didn't work with Mae. It almost appeared like he wasn't even part of the band - like he wanted to show off and make noise instead, and solo instead of playing parts that the fans know and love.
Between me and the dozen or so people around me from different social groups, by the time the finale started, most were gone. It was sad - I wish I hadn't wasted hours out of my weekend (2 hour drive from Richmond) to go see this mediocre performance.