I've seen Jay about six times in the past few years, driving two hours once, just to finally hear, "Cara, Mia", in person. I was NOT disappointed, but, impressed that at 69 then, and 72 now, Jay still hits those high notes and has a great, funny personality. I could listen to him sing and/or tell his stories all night!
Not to take away from Gary Puckett. This, as fas as I can recall, was my first time seeing him and he still sounds great and has a great onstage personality as well. He was gracious enough to meet with his fans after the show, which was very much appreciated.