so the concert kicked ass!!!!!! i had my doubts that they could replicate such intricate layers from the recording live, but damn they did it. it has been a long time since i have seen a band with a three-guitar attack. and they used it all the way.
it really struck me how seeing a band live really gives you a feeling of the core of the band - who they are and how they communicate. this is definitely a band surrounding the core dude - doug martsch. he literally didn't say more than "thank you" throughout the 1.5 hour performance. introverted, sure, but man how feeling comes through in his singing. i didn't realize that he was bald with a beard! my first comment to my wife was that he looks like me! ;) she said he even sounded like me, but a higher pitch. very much my style, she said. even wore a similar t-shirt to what i would wear. i, thankfully, no longer have anything close to his beer belly. ;)
they had a completely random song order - jumping from one album to another, one intensity to another, seemingly with no logic whatsoever. there was no flow from one song to the next. but i guess when a lot of the songs are 7 min+ it doesn't matter as much. i was really reminded of the two-track form of writing - either catchy jingle-type thing or 7-minute opus with all sorts of twists & turns and different tempos even. from allmusic.com i figure the lineup has been stable for at least 10 years so these guys were tight and that was a joy to experience. especially on these mini rock-operas.
verging on prog territory, even, i would admit. so i actually thought back to the earlier e-mails while at the concert! i think that these guys really are somewhat in prog territory at times. the complicated rhythmic patterns and ambitious songs that soar.
there were a few moments when i felt transported to his mind's concept of the song. with three guitars creating an idyllic wall of sound it's really like riding a (sound) wave. but so so admirable the control and dynamics of the band as a whole. they would rise up and come back down as a unit without even looking at one another - they wear the years well. there was not a single second of indulgent overblown feedback or yelling - it was what we were all looking for somehow - to feel release - but they weren't going there. admirable songcraft control. which i would contrast with the shins. the shins also had ridiculous control, but in a bad way. i didn't feel that they felt anything as they played. it was exactly the record. period. no emotion. these guys, you felt the sincerity coming through. so much intangible to explain with tangible words. writing about music is truly like dancing about architecture (credits to elvis costello, frank zappa or whoever first said that).
allmusic said that built to spill connects the dots between dinosaur jr and the flaming lips' surreal wigouts. i would agree with that. but what adds a new texture is his voice. he has this soothing, aching thing that gives it a nice dichotomy and complexity. my wife said the music made her so comfortable.
on the subject of the new album, however, i would say that the new songs didn't quite work! i was surprised. it was like they haven't worn them long enough to be as comfortable as the old running shoes. songs off of you in reverse (2006) really rocked in a fresh way, but this new album came off more cold and calculated, like pop songs out of place almost. whereas on listening i didn't get that sense, and allmusic seemed to go along with me on that. will need more time to ruminate.