Michael Feinstein is a marvelous performer and his encyclopedic knowledge of the American Songbook music, composers, and performers is invaluable -- and it is what we expected him to draw on at the Hollywood Bowl. Instead, we got very little of the Songbook and a lot of wasted time.
He - or whoever drew up the program - underestimated the audience members, thinking that they would rather see old T.V. clips and listen to patter about "what a wonderful evening this is" and "how great [insert name] is" than actually see quality performances of the great standards.
Feinstein introduced Florence Henderson as "Richard Rogers's favorite singer", but she didn't sing anything by Rogers - all we got was a schlock version of "Side by Side" written by Harry Woods. Worse - and directly insulting - was having to sit through a sing-along of the Brady Bunch theme song. Dick Van Dyke was little better: one song from Mary Poppins would have been enough. His first words were that he wasn't going to do music from the Song Book. What a waste. Cheyenne Jackson has a magnificent voice - what a shame it wasn't used to deliver some of the classic standards. Wayne Brady came closest with "You Send Me", but that's still a marginal selection.
For all of Feinstein's talk about the Great American Song Book, we had an evening without anything from the Gershwins, Cole Porter, Johnny Mercer, Rogers & Hart, Hoagy Carmichael, Harry Warren, Harold Arlen or others of that calibre. We got one song from Irving Berlin and one from Jerome Kern/Dorothy Fields.
The night was beautiful, the Bowl is a great venue, the talent was prodigious, and all but a small fraction of those wonderful resources were squandered on pap. The program began marvelously with Feinstein's rendition of "The Way You Look Tonight", but went downhill from there. Irving Berlin's "I Love a Piano" right before intermission raised hopes that the second act would be better, but it wasn't. Closing with "New York, New York" was enjoyable, but hardly a top tier work. Overall, the show was a true disappointment. Feinstein should know better, or at least insist that those who work with and for him know better if he wasn't the one who designed the program.